Discover Your Treasure...

    SAVE 20% on a chain or leather cord when you purchase any treasure. Use coupon code: CHAIN

    We add new blogs and videos weekly - join our email list below for quick notification!

    Double-Sided Atocha Pirate's Toothpick Lion Earrings in Shipwreck Silver | #5447MC

    Size Guide
    Size Guide for Ladies & Gentlemen
    Pendant Necklace and Ring Size Guide
    Size Guide for Ladies & Gentlemen
    Pendant Necklace and Ring Size Guide

    Our "Pirate's Toothpick" once sailed aboard Mel Fisher's Atocha!

    The original artifact from which this toothpick was cast is made of 22 KT gold! Spanish aristocracy sailing aboard the treasure galleons used this little tool to clean their finger nails and pick their teeth… hopefully not in that order! They were custom-made for each individual, and they have unique designs requested by the user.

    The lion toothpick was recovered from the Atocha off Key West, Florida, and the cupid toothpick was recovered by Robert’s treasure diving buddy and mentor, Captain Carl Fismer from the 1715 Treasure Fleet off Vero Beach, Florida. Both originals have been displayed in Mel Fisher’s museums.

    Today we affectionately call these amazing artifacts “Pirates Tooth Picks” and they can serve the same purpose they originally did… or they can be worn by a lady or gentleman adventurer as a single pendant, or added to a chain to compliment another pendant. The late Duke Long, one of Robert’s old treasure diving friends and mentors, and a jewelry artist himself, added a “Pirates Tooth Pick” to one of Robert’s first Spanish treasure coins. And, Robert hasn’t worn it since he proposed to April and she commandeered it!

    The Spanish Lion "Pirate Toothpick" Pendant

    Shipwreck Silver

    Theses Pirate's Toothpicks are cast with our exclusive blend of shipwreck silver from four shipwrecks: Atocha - 1622, the 1715 Fleet, Le Chameu - 1725 and Santa Leocadia - 1800. To read about how we blend our authentic shipwreck silver, where the treasure came from, and the history of these shipwrecks, check out Robert's Blog "Shipwreck Silver - the Story Behind the Story."

    Of Special Note: Our exclusive Empires Collection features Museum-Quality Castings that are produced by hand, in the USA, and to exacting standards, creating jewelry pieces that are amazingly faithful to the original artifact.  Each is hand-finished here in the studio - toned, hand-rubbed and polished - making the best of ancient art affordable and wearable for a life-time.

    Your Empires Collection Earrings Comes Complete with:

    1. A Detailed, Two Page Historic Brief Researched and Written by Robert Lewis Knecht
    2. A Linen Gift Pouch
    3. A Treasure Jewelry Care Card